Capitol Daybook Research
← All ballot measures

November 3, 2020 General Election

Proposition 23

Establishes State Requirements for Kidney Dialysis Clinics. Requires On-Site Medical Professional. Initiative Statute.

What it does

Proposition 23 would have required each kidney dialysis clinic to have a doctor on site during all treatment hours, at clinic expense, with a state approved exception allowing a nurse practitioner or physician assistant where there is a doctor shortage. Clinics also would have had to report infection related information every three months, obtain state consent before closing or substantially reducing services, and not refuse care based on who pays. The Legislative Analyst estimated state and local costs likely in the low tens of millions of dollars annually.

Written from the Legislative Analyst's analysis of this measure.

Official summary

ESTABLISHES STATE REQUIREMENTS FOR KIDNEY DIALYSIS CLINICS. REQUIRES ON-SITE MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL. INITIATIVE STATUTE. Requires physician, nurse practitioner or physician assistant on site during dialysis treatment. Prohibits clinics from reducing services without state approval. Prohibits clinics from refusing to treat patients based on payment source. Fiscal Impact: Increased state and local government costs likely in the low tens of millions of dollars annually.

The Attorney General's summary as printed for voters. Official voter guide

About this measure

How it qualified

Initiative statute. Initiative 19-0025A1, qualified by voter signatures.

Analysis and official text

Legislative Analyst's analysis · Official voter guide

Related measures

  • Proposition 29 (November 8, 2022 General Election) shared committee + shared topic: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (c)(5)) - Yes on 23 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection; Yes on 23 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection, sponsored by Service Employees International Union - United Healthcare Workers West; Dialysis clinic regulation
  • Proposition 8 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee + shared topic: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (c)(5)) - Yes on 8 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection; Yes on 8 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection, Sponsored by Service Employees International Union - United Healthcare Workers West; Dialysis clinic regulation
  • Proposition 52 (November 8, 2016 General Election) shared committee: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (C)(5))

Related measures

Part of a recurring issue: Dialysis clinic regulation. Also on the ballot in other elections: Proposition 8 (November 6, 2018 General Election): Failed; Proposition 29 (November 8, 2022 General Election): Failed.

Statewide result

YesNoYes shareMarginResult
6,161,45710,681,17136.58%No by 26.8 pts (4,519,714 votes)Failed

Certified statewide results, Secretary of State Statement of Vote.

Results by district

Assembly districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Assembly District 160,107186,11424.41%
Assembly District 283,102151,06035.49%
Assembly District 355,058149,74826.88%
Assembly District 475,259148,84433.58%
Assembly District 557,593171,61625.13%
Assembly District 676,167228,80724.97%
Assembly District 780,490132,80637.74%
Assembly District 870,761160,83530.55%
Assembly District 975,441141,94434.7%
Assembly District 1092,920166,40935.83%
Assembly District 1184,893148,72636.34%
Assembly District 1261,518155,65328.33%
Assembly District 1364,463108,10337.36%
Assembly District 1489,641144,80238.24%
Assembly District 15119,716127,64648.4%
Assembly District 1695,219193,88632.94%
Assembly District 17114,847120,97448.7%
Assembly District 18111,078110,85550.05%
Assembly District 19104,012130,88244.28%
Assembly District 2085,474116,41342.34%
Assembly District 2153,711103,16634.24%
Assembly District 2289,918152,01837.17%
Assembly District 2369,635163,21929.91%
Assembly District 2477,157139,38335.63%
Assembly District 2582,624112,52542.34%
Assembly District 2647,766109,51830.37%
Assembly District 2783,00795,53246.49%
Assembly District 2885,758152,60035.98%
Assembly District 2998,145155,78138.65%
Assembly District 3072,311106,49240.44%
Assembly District 3149,23276,89239.03%
Assembly District 3238,40367,24236.35%
Assembly District 3356,229127,73630.57%
Assembly District 3455,229160,15525.64%
Assembly District 3569,038156,84830.56%
Assembly District 3666,292121,89035.23%
Assembly District 3796,589148,41439.42%
Assembly District 3879,382174,75531.24%
Assembly District 3974,40696,93343.43%
Assembly District 4066,488129,35533.95%
Assembly District 4187,332162,87934.9%
Assembly District 4268,171157,11630.26%
Assembly District 4395,842122,71943.85%
Assembly District 4474,315146,02733.73%
Assembly District 4582,128138,07837.3%
Assembly District 4685,923109,04844.07%
Assembly District 4763,783100,50538.82%
Assembly District 4869,590112,67838.18%
Assembly District 4964,971100,79139.2%
Assembly District 50104,360154,23640.36%
Assembly District 5189,39280,87952.5%
Assembly District 5265,517104,25338.59%
Assembly District 5370,78158,93754.57%
Assembly District 54101,049121,14345.48%
Assembly District 5573,765155,89732.12%
Assembly District 5662,16792,09440.3%
Assembly District 5774,328122,39137.78%
Assembly District 5875,079109,18240.75%
Assembly District 5960,71256,65051.73%
Assembly District 6065,803130,32033.55%
Assembly District 6166,197112,39537.07%
Assembly District 6292,025114,04044.66%
Assembly District 6366,98385,07644.05%
Assembly District 6468,83583,84145.09%
Assembly District 6572,107121,70237.21%
Assembly District 6675,449166,27431.21%
Assembly District 6772,132173,97729.31%
Assembly District 6882,431173,64232.19%
Assembly District 6960,59276,04644.34%
Assembly District 7082,523124,52939.86%
Assembly District 7165,011165,86728.16%
Assembly District 7278,355147,08134.76%
Assembly District 7374,543201,75826.98%
Assembly District 7484,063178,31332.04%
Assembly District 7574,337163,80731.22%
Assembly District 7680,876155,54634.21%
Assembly District 7790,022176,45533.78%
Assembly District 78101,777147,83540.77%
Assembly District 7992,652136,35940.46%
Assembly District 8076,70794,45744.81%

Senate districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
State Senate District 1134,320412,13024.58%
State Senate District 2170,087309,05135.5%
State Senate District 3167,128303,11635.54%
State Senate District 4122,496322,87427.5%
State Senate District 5128,744266,64032.56%
State Senate District 6164,373275,08337.4%
State Senate District 7181,442337,97934.93%
State Senate District 8130,276333,76028.07%
State Senate District 9231,446239,67449.13%
State Senate District 10168,618229,78942.32%
State Senate District 11217,934250,71746.5%
State Senate District 12109,598187,80436.85%
State Senate District 13167,222290,97736.5%
State Senate District 1482,049136,53637.54%
State Senate District 15168,947253,67839.98%
State Senate District 16105,357281,68427.22%
State Senate District 17176,036313,68235.95%
State Senate District 18160,715205,50743.88%
State Senate District 19160,244261,02538.04%
State Senate District 20129,300204,75838.71%
State Senate District 21133,186263,86133.54%
State Senate District 22133,484197,06340.38%
State Senate District 23134,213300,08930.9%
State Senate District 24165,451141,97353.82%
State Senate District 25171,122297,93636.48%
State Senate District 26185,517317,96636.85%
State Senate District 27164,393326,94933.46%
State Senate District 28137,907303,43431.25%
State Senate District 29144,601272,76534.65%
State Senate District 30168,238180,22048.28%
State Senate District 31132,000242,71535.23%
State Senate District 32152,834246,52638.27%
State Senate District 33137,882161,63746.03%
State Senate District 34141,531237,26537.36%
State Senate District 35150,814199,83643.01%
State Senate District 36156,863360,91030.3%
State Senate District 37167,300354,03132.09%
State Senate District 38148,095334,84830.67%
State Senate District 39196,300307,79738.94%
State Senate District 40155,998208,25042.83%

Congressional districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Congressional District 187,958263,46625.03%
Congressional District 2136,320244,01435.84%
Congressional District 3102,026215,81932.1%
Congressional District 4107,164327,34924.66%
Congressional District 5127,953224,88336.26%
Congressional District 6117,397190,41438.14%
Congressional District 7114,862262,65530.43%
Congressional District 885,808199,70230.05%
Congressional District 9103,799199,83334.19%
Congressional District 1094,236205,22531.47%
Congressional District 11140,079230,74337.78%
Congressional District 12172,506195,36546.89%
Congressional District 13179,063181,52849.66%
Congressional District 14137,164205,61740.02%
Congressional District 15136,030212,66339.01%
Congressional District 1677,339136,70136.13%
Congressional District 17120,801174,50040.91%
Congressional District 18127,327239,60534.7%
Congressional District 19131,010181,46841.93%
Congressional District 20123,924177,24641.15%
Congressional District 2161,350107,79936.27%
Congressional District 2292,496216,61429.92%
Congressional District 2381,760221,37126.97%
Congressional District 24121,357230,32934.51%
Congressional District 25111,242224,68833.11%
Congressional District 26120,263224,08534.92%
Congressional District 27119,531200,67537.33%
Congressional District 28151,867181,49545.56%
Congressional District 29109,314131,04545.48%
Congressional District 30137,635219,16738.57%
Congressional District 31100,697188,69934.8%
Congressional District 32104,481166,98838.49%
Congressional District 33128,864261,07033.05%
Congressional District 34121,302105,98753.37%
Congressional District 3596,952151,73438.99%
Congressional District 3699,184203,39632.78%
Congressional District 37144,125166,98246.33%
Congressional District 38115,257187,67838.05%
Congressional District 39112,755227,50833.14%
Congressional District 4092,840103,32347.33%
Congressional District 4195,828166,02036.6%
Congressional District 42110,083257,41729.95%
Congressional District 43121,746158,47743.45%
Congressional District 44103,454128,40044.62%
Congressional District 45128,143276,16131.69%
Congressional District 4695,604131,66242.07%
Congressional District 47120,388192,12538.52%
Congressional District 48119,692266,91830.96%
Congressional District 49119,594258,83931.6%
Congressional District 50104,755253,24629.26%
Congressional District 51108,798132,43945.1%
Congressional District 52136,817250,32135.34%
ca-53150,764219,94640.67%

District lines in effect for this election (2011 lines).

Election results

2020 General Election: Yes took 36.6% statewide.

Precinct-level results and breakdowns are in the Election Reports.

Who funded the campaigns

The largest committee on each side of this measure, and that committee's largest funders in the Secretary of State filings compiled for this library.

Supporting: Yes on 23 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection, sponsored by Service Employees International Union - United Healthcare Workers West

  • SEIU United Healthcare Workers West Political Issues Committee
  • SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED HEALTHCARE WORKERS WEST ( NONPROFIT 501(C) (5) )
  • California Democratic Party

Opposing: No on 23 - Stop the Dangerous & Costly Dialysis Proposition, a Coalition of Dialysis Providers, Nurses, Doctors and Patients

  • DA VITA INC.
  • FRESENIUS MEDICAL CARE
  • U.S. RENAL CARE
  • US Renal Care, Inc.
  • SATELLITE HEALTHCARE, INC.