Capitol Daybook Research
← All ballot measures

November 6, 2018 General Election

Proposition 8

Regulates Amounts Outpatient Kidney Dialysis Clinics Charge for Dialysis Treatment. Initiative Statute.

What it does

Proposition 8 would have capped outpatient kidney dialysis clinic revenues at 115 percent of specified direct patient care and health care quality improvement costs, calculated at the owner or operator level. Clinics would have had to rebate amounts above the cap to payers other than Medicare and other government payers, with interest, plus a penalty of 5 percent of rebates, up to $100,000. It also would have required annual reports to the state and barred clinics from refusing treatment based on who pays.

Written from the Legislative Analyst's analysis of this measure.

Official summary

REGULATES AMOUNTS OUTPATIENT KIDNEY DIALYSIS CLINICS CHARGE FOR DIALYSIS TREATMENT. INITIATIVE STATUTE. Requires rebates and penalties if charges exceed limit. Requires annual reporting to the state. Prohibits clinics from refusing to treat patients based on payment source. Fiscal Impact: Overall annual effect on state and local governments ranging from net positive impact in the low tens of millions of dollars to net negative impact in the tens of millions of dollars.

The Attorney General's summary as printed for voters. Official voter guide

About this measure

How it qualified

Initiative statute. Initiative 17-0014A1, qualified by voter signatures.

Analysis and official text

Legislative Analyst's analysis · Official voter guide

Related measures

  • Proposition 29 (November 8, 2022 General Election) shared committee + shared topic: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (c)(5)) - Yes on 8 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection; Yes on 8 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection, Sponsored by Service Employees International Union - United Healthcare Workers West; Dialysis clinic regulation
  • Proposition 23 (November 3, 2020 General Election) shared committee + shared topic: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (c)(5)) - Yes on 8 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection; Yes on 8 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection, Sponsored by Service Employees International Union - United Healthcare Workers West; Dialysis clinic regulation
  • Proposition 52 (November 8, 2016 General Election) shared committee: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (C)(5))

Related measures

Part of a recurring issue: Dialysis clinic regulation. Also on the ballot in other elections: Proposition 23 (November 3, 2020 General Election): Failed; Proposition 29 (November 8, 2022 General Election): Failed.

Statewide result

YesNoYes shareMarginResult
4,845,2647,247,91740.07%No by 19.9 pts (2,402,653 votes)Failed

Certified statewide results, Secretary of State Statement of Vote.

Results by district

Assembly districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Assembly District 164,514131,61532.89%
Assembly District 281,431101,54544.5%
Assembly District 350,899106,40432.36%
Assembly District 469,627102,19140.52%
Assembly District 558,190118,08433.01%
Assembly District 672,280153,92431.95%
Assembly District 764,91186,91342.75%
Assembly District 861,877108,40036.34%
Assembly District 960,29993,79339.13%
Assembly District 1091,563121,01343.07%
Assembly District 1161,08496,95038.65%
Assembly District 1251,671105,13032.95%
Assembly District 1345,29368,83839.69%
Assembly District 1473,01498,26042.63%
Assembly District 15110,13491,89954.51%
Assembly District 1684,429132,94938.84%
Assembly District 17121,07482,17259.57%
Assembly District 1892,01478,09554.09%
Assembly District 1998,46186,15553.33%
Assembly District 2061,89975,03445.2%
Assembly District 2137,80371,16134.69%
Assembly District 2281,965107,73943.21%
Assembly District 2350,436114,09430.65%
Assembly District 2470,857102,89240.78%
Assembly District 2563,25567,78748.27%
Assembly District 2631,18176,42228.98%
Assembly District 2758,33458,84749.78%
Assembly District 2879,329101,97143.76%
Assembly District 2990,505111,71444.76%
Assembly District 3049,49571,48640.91%
Assembly District 3129,10255,46434.41%
Assembly District 3222,32245,75232.79%
Assembly District 3336,30482,92030.45%
Assembly District 3439,983103,93427.78%
Assembly District 3560,147111,93734.95%
Assembly District 3642,18285,04333.16%
Assembly District 3783,474107,15043.79%
Assembly District 3865,747118,32135.72%
Assembly District 3945,33964,75641.18%
Assembly District 4046,18284,10735.45%
Assembly District 4171,651115,52938.28%
Assembly District 4252,204102,66033.71%
Assembly District 4374,25084,00846.92%
Assembly District 4459,670101,53237.02%
Assembly District 4561,59192,24340.04%
Assembly District 4663,78775,86445.68%
Assembly District 4735,09661,50536.33%
Assembly District 4843,23875,32436.47%
Assembly District 4944,14461,46241.8%
Assembly District 5094,636110,16046.21%
Assembly District 5160,29361,33549.57%
Assembly District 5237,94565,88036.55%
Assembly District 5342,13043,42649.24%
Assembly District 5483,84490,42748.11%
Assembly District 5557,721103,35035.84%
Assembly District 5635,82859,35937.64%
Assembly District 5747,69183,11836.46%
Assembly District 5846,69075,38238.25%
Assembly District 5932,71443,71142.81%
Assembly District 6042,95882,32734.29%
Assembly District 6139,72373,22735.17%
Assembly District 6270,20480,20146.68%
Assembly District 6338,18562,12938.07%
Assembly District 6439,61460,43039.6%
Assembly District 6551,56978,75839.57%
Assembly District 6665,818111,33237.15%
Assembly District 6748,007105,55131.26%
Assembly District 6866,605115,00436.67%
Assembly District 6936,65850,48442.07%
Assembly District 7062,71686,54242.02%
Assembly District 7152,999112,38632.05%
Assembly District 7263,00795,28339.8%
Assembly District 7372,100133,80535.02%
Assembly District 7476,939120,71738.93%
Assembly District 7558,665110,05434.77%
Assembly District 7670,508107,92339.52%
Assembly District 7777,135119,67139.19%
Assembly District 7893,313101,72747.84%
Assembly District 7966,11289,25242.55%
Assembly District 8048,70061,97844%

Senate districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
State Senate District 1138,149284,16832.71%
State Senate District 2166,504215,18843.62%
State Senate District 3144,469208,68040.91%
State Senate District 4110,609221,44633.31%
State Senate District 599,466174,55036.3%
State Senate District 6132,369184,71941.75%
State Senate District 7148,716226,70739.61%
State Senate District 8106,778231,27831.59%
State Senate District 9202,609170,69754.27%
State Senate District 10126,117143,73246.74%
State Senate District 11218,879167,65556.63%
State Senate District 1271,797129,45035.68%
State Senate District 13152,739210,17442.09%
State Senate District 1447,45995,86233.11%
State Senate District 15139,262164,70745.81%
State Senate District 1674,747186,34728.63%
State Senate District 17157,891220,87541.69%
State Senate District 18109,280141,15643.64%
State Senate District 19126,954185,55340.62%
State Senate District 2073,041127,38536.44%
State Senate District 2187,772178,23933%
State Senate District 2283,795126,97039.76%
State Senate District 2395,093193,61732.94%
State Senate District 24110,529107,70650.65%
State Senate District 25136,707204,97940.01%
State Senate District 26172,740227,72543.13%
State Senate District 27135,075223,19337.7%
State Senate District 2897,692191,49933.78%
State Senate District 29108,194179,23137.64%
State Senate District 30121,335135,17047.3%
State Senate District 3182,681155,55434.71%
State Senate District 3299,400166,63737.36%
State Senate District 3383,038117,97441.31%
State Senate District 34104,842157,09640.03%
State Senate District 3599,998136,92242.21%
State Senate District 36143,969244,30337.08%
State Senate District 37144,296237,04037.84%
State Senate District 38121,397229,15934.63%
State Senate District 39171,941211,46244.85%
State Senate District 4096,935133,11242.14%

Congressional districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Congressional District 192,487190,62132.67%
Congressional District 2136,343170,83144.39%
Congressional District 382,691145,36936.26%
Congressional District 4107,710222,57132.61%
Congressional District 5112,615154,31342.19%
Congressional District 693,805126,03042.67%
Congressional District 7100,180177,08936.13%
Congressional District 859,648130,69831.34%
Congressional District 975,265125,79337.43%
Congressional District 1076,202141,45235.01%
Congressional District 11119,587159,80042.8%
Congressional District 12181,748132,10757.91%
Congressional District 13162,318130,38255.46%
Congressional District 14118,965141,96945.59%
Congressional District 15102,237139,41542.31%
Congressional District 1648,61392,53634.44%
Congressional District 1797,098107,97947.35%
Congressional District 18120,967171,84041.31%
Congressional District 1999,807115,30546.4%
Congressional District 2098,677126,45243.83%
Congressional District 2136,28275,35632.5%
Congressional District 2264,471152,59029.7%
Congressional District 2357,360144,95928.35%
Congressional District 24108,413166,87039.38%
Congressional District 2583,607155,42734.98%
Congressional District 2696,104155,68038.17%
Congressional District 2792,270134,52140.69%
Congressional District 28118,980127,25748.32%
Congressional District 2966,25488,04042.94%
Congressional District 30107,518149,28241.87%
Congressional District 3166,601119,90935.71%
Congressional District 3265,248112,09836.79%
Congressional District 33123,651182,85140.34%
Congressional District 3478,25377,82450.14%
Congressional District 3554,38295,35136.32%
Congressional District 3670,051132,49034.59%
Congressional District 37110,913124,42647.13%
Congressional District 3874,856127,43237%
Congressional District 3988,262151,52236.81%
Congressional District 4048,80277,13838.75%
Congressional District 4158,313108,45434.97%
Congressional District 4274,086156,60632.11%
Congressional District 4388,484106,23345.44%
Congressional District 4458,94593,65538.63%
Congressional District 45112,139183,96837.87%
Congressional District 4660,26186,58041.04%
Congressional District 4789,978128,97241.1%
Congressional District 48106,938178,95537.4%
Congressional District 49109,698176,11038.38%
Congressional District 5085,438172,00133.19%
Congressional District 5165,46986,24743.15%
Congressional District 52119,787168,88241.5%
ca-53116,487147,67944.1%

District lines in effect for this election (2011 lines).

Election results

2018 General Election: Yes took 40.1% statewide.

Precinct-level results and breakdowns are in the Election Reports.

Who funded the campaigns

The largest committee on each side of this measure, and that committee's largest funders in the Secretary of State filings compiled for this library.

Supporting: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (c)(5)) - Yes on 8 - Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection

Opposing: No on Proposition 8: Stop the Dangerous Dialysis Proposition, Sponsored by the California Dialysis Council

  • DA VITA INC.
  • Fresenius Medical Care North America
  • US Renal Care, Inc.
  • Dialysis Clinic, Inc.
  • DaVita