Capitol Daybook Research
← All ballot measures

November 8, 2016 General Election

Proposition 52

State Fees on Hospitals. Federal Medi-Cal Matching Funds. Initiative Constitutional Amendment and Statute.

What it does

Proposition 52 extends the state fee on hospitals permanently and uses the fee to draw federal Medi-Cal matching funds. Ending the fee would require a two-thirds vote of each house of the Legislature, and changes would generally require voter approval. Fee revenue is excluded from the calculation of minimum school funding. The Legislative Analyst estimated that, if the Legislature would not otherwise have extended the fee, it would provide General Fund savings of about $1 billion and funding to public hospitals in the low hundreds of millions of dollars.

Written from the Legislative Analyst's analysis of this measure.

Official summary

STATE FEES ON HOSPITALS. FEDERAL MEDI-CAL MATCHING FUNDS. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT AND STATUTE. Increases required vote to two-thirds for the Legislature to amend a certain existing law that imposes fees on hospitals (for purpose of obtaining federal Medi-Cal matching funds) and that directs those fees and federal matching funds to hospital-provided Medi-Cal health care services, to uncompensated care provided by hospitals to uninsured patients, and to children's health coverage. Eliminates law's ending date. Declares that law's fee proceeds shall not be considered revenues for purposes of applying state spending limit or determining required education funding. Summary of estimate by Legislative Analyst and Director of Finance of fiscal impact on state and local government: State savings from increased revenues that offset state costs for children's health coverage of around $500 million beginning in 2016-17 (half-year savings) to over $1 billion annually by 2019-20, likely growing between 5 percent to 10 percent annually thereafter. Increased revenues to support state and local public hospitals of around $90 million beginning in 2016-17 (half-year) to $250 million annually by 2019-20, likely growing between 5 percent to 10 percent annually thereafter.

The Attorney General's summary as printed for voters. Official voter guide

About this measure

How it qualified

Initiative constitutional amendment and statute. Initiative 13-0022, qualified by voter signatures.

Analysis and official text

Legislative Analyst's analysis · Official voter guide

Related measures

  • Proposition 35 (November 5, 2024 General Election) shared topic: Health care funding
  • Proposition 29 (November 8, 2022 General Election) shared committee: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (C)(5))
  • Proposition 23 (November 3, 2020 General Election) shared committee: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (C)(5))
  • Proposition 8 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (C)(5))

Related measures

Part of a recurring issue: Health care funding. Also on the ballot in other elections: Proposition 35 (November 5, 2024 General Election): Passed.

Statewide result

YesNoYes shareMarginResult
9,427,7144,026,71070.07%Yes by 40.1 pts (5,401,004 votes)Passed

Certified statewide results, Secretary of State Statement of Vote.

Results by district

Assembly districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Assembly District 1128,55684,09260.45%
Assembly District 2141,07362,28869.37%
Assembly District 3108,75763,78063.03%
Assembly District 4129,19559,14468.6%
Assembly District 5113,38076,30359.77%
Assembly District 6143,89491,56361.11%
Assembly District 7115,46946,48871.3%
Assembly District 8122,73561,21366.72%
Assembly District 9112,87153,52167.83%
Assembly District 10169,70857,52074.69%
Assembly District 11115,14661,13065.32%
Assembly District 12107,96661,50463.71%
Assembly District 1392,37040,56969.48%
Assembly District 14134,61554,99071%
Assembly District 15179,09439,79981.82%
Assembly District 16158,92875,01767.93%
Assembly District 17176,67340,18481.47%
Assembly District 18151,49735,58980.98%
Assembly District 19151,79247,56076.14%
Assembly District 20115,74942,86972.97%
Assembly District 2184,86939,67568.14%
Assembly District 22148,51453,94873.35%
Assembly District 23109,71367,79361.81%
Assembly District 24141,35049,55374.04%
Assembly District 25109,40544,60871.04%
Assembly District 2675,41145,90162.16%
Assembly District 27104,89136,01474.44%
Assembly District 28142,99761,64369.88%
Assembly District 29157,54459,15772.7%
Assembly District 3096,72842,14869.65%
Assembly District 3165,97530,55668.35%
Assembly District 3254,37427,31666.56%
Assembly District 3391,91752,11563.82%
Assembly District 34100,87869,13459.34%
Assembly District 35123,32565,32865.37%
Assembly District 3696,51450,36865.71%
Assembly District 37150,46560,11871.45%
Assembly District 38126,70369,25164.66%
Assembly District 3998,38534,32274.14%
Assembly District 40104,19749,12767.96%
Assembly District 41144,22059,25970.88%
Assembly District 42113,19959,41465.58%
Assembly District 43129,52442,33875.37%
Assembly District 44125,47757,06068.74%
Assembly District 45123,41649,32771.44%
Assembly District 46117,83734,38777.41%
Assembly District 4787,17833,53172.22%
Assembly District 48100,18039,67471.63%
Assembly District 4984,20135,18370.53%
Assembly District 50167,39547,56777.87%
Assembly District 51110,24425,31181.33%
Assembly District 5287,18536,20170.66%
Assembly District 5376,64218,62180.45%
Assembly District 54153,70934,25881.77%
Assembly District 55113,45261,71864.77%
Assembly District 5685,03535,13070.77%
Assembly District 57107,13444,81970.5%
Assembly District 58104,49838,96972.84%
Assembly District 5978,74716,40082.76%
Assembly District 6093,12750,08965.03%
Assembly District 6196,58443,66868.86%
Assembly District 62129,71736,07078.24%
Assembly District 6390,00530,28274.83%
Assembly District 6496,83025,98878.84%
Assembly District 65103,97644,84469.87%
Assembly District 66129,98162,23167.62%
Assembly District 67108,82565,57562.4%
Assembly District 68126,20367,21765.25%
Assembly District 6977,38826,54374.46%
Assembly District 70117,98246,26471.83%
Assembly District 71117,33167,09163.62%
Assembly District 72116,39155,28367.8%
Assembly District 73138,79977,13664.28%
Assembly District 74138,94567,15567.42%
Assembly District 75115,47866,45463.47%
Assembly District 76128,21160,02068.11%
Assembly District 77146,49564,84969.32%
Assembly District 78158,29152,95274.93%
Assembly District 79128,70749,00972.42%
Assembly District 80105,55835,62874.77%

Senate districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
State Senate District 1271,800177,30860.52%
State Senate District 2301,036117,62971.9%
State Senate District 3265,294119,48568.95%
State Senate District 4230,671130,80963.81%
State Senate District 5203,816103,90766.23%
State Senate District 6239,86998,60570.87%
State Senate District 7279,130131,65067.95%
State Senate District 8223,446139,91561.49%
State Senate District 9331,41775,83581.38%
State Senate District 10226,89187,64472.14%
State Senate District 11327,33487,38878.93%
State Senate District 12155,46675,38467.35%
State Senate District 13289,536103,29273.71%
State Senate District 14114,28554,60367.67%
State Senate District 15250,393100,19171.42%
State Senate District 16183,187120,83860.25%
State Senate District 17286,704122,87370%
State Senate District 18216,41868,90875.85%
State Senate District 19248,879105,92670.15%
State Senate District 20174,36369,73271.43%
State Senate District 21198,920105,49165.35%
State Senate District 22178,15568,49372.23%
State Senate District 23217,257116,92265.01%
State Senate District 24197,00844,68081.51%
State Senate District 25265,766107,72271.16%
State Senate District 26316,708108,29274.52%
State Senate District 27269,867123,00468.69%
State Senate District 28213,901112,16565.6%
State Senate District 29215,112104,85167.23%
State Senate District 30235,99650,77282.3%
State Senate District 31189,71193,75766.93%
State Senate District 32218,36889,51370.93%
State Senate District 33180,86256,79176.1%
State Senate District 34203,06787,75469.83%
State Senate District 35209,31966,30775.94%
State Senate District 36269,629138,69766.03%
State Senate District 37266,613135,15066.36%
State Senate District 38246,953133,30164.94%
State Senate District 39304,450110,26473.41%
State Senate District 40210,12380,86572.21%

Congressional districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Congressional District 1189,616117,32361.78%
Congressional District 2240,95292,58972.24%
Congressional District 3164,40189,98464.63%
Congressional District 4209,766137,38160.43%
Congressional District 5207,03586,01870.65%
Congressional District 6169,71966,72871.78%
Congressional District 7194,278100,61865.88%
Congressional District 8142,71182,96863.24%
Congressional District 9152,17479,65465.64%
Congressional District 10155,19880,01365.98%
Congressional District 11218,98785,38471.95%
Congressional District 12265,87367,79079.68%
Congressional District 13263,63054,41582.89%
Congressional District 14209,08572,55674.24%
Congressional District 15190,30682,01469.88%
Congressional District 16112,42752,45868.19%
Congressional District 17169,73868,87971.13%
Congressional District 18231,44691,84771.59%
Congressional District 19179,94570,49071.85%
Congressional District 20181,11366,29073.21%
Congressional District 2185,20644,80165.54%
Congressional District 22144,74389,84961.7%
Congressional District 23143,85795,59360.08%
Congressional District 24205,60895,88568.2%
Congressional District 25169,54489,99565.33%
Congressional District 26196,22887,78669.09%
Congressional District 27176,86271,10471.33%
Congressional District 28205,18061,28577%
Congressional District 29139,68343,73476.16%
Congressional District 30205,11776,77772.76%
Congressional District 31152,72569,27368.8%
Congressional District 32148,76159,42971.45%
Congressional District 33235,52690,82272.17%
Congressional District 34138,07433,18980.62%
Congressional District 35129,68752,06071.36%
Congressional District 36157,40172,61168.43%
Congressional District 37210,32446,54681.88%
Congressional District 38166,12767,62971.07%
Congressional District 39172,70888,50366.12%
Congressional District 40120,51834,99177.5%
Congressional District 41138,42464,48968.22%
Congressional District 42162,34897,57062.46%
Congressional District 43167,72252,08476.3%
Congressional District 44142,73842,99976.85%
Congressional District 45204,448106,15765.82%
Congressional District 46127,34647,02173.03%
Congressional District 47172,77271,53170.72%
Congressional District 48199,135101,56966.22%
Congressional District 49200,93298,49267.11%
Congressional District 50176,505103,65363%
Congressional District 51145,96452,71573.47%
Congressional District 52221,03891,21270.79%
ca-53216,06979,96072.99%

District lines in effect for this election (2011 lines).

Election results

2016 General Election: Yes took 70.1% statewide.

Precinct-level results and breakdowns are in the Election Reports.

Who funded the campaigns

The largest committee on each side of this measure, and that committee's largest funders in the Secretary of State filings compiled for this library.

Supporting: Yes on Proposition 52 - A Coalition of California Association of Hospitals and Health Systems and Non-Profit Health Care Organizations

  • Dignity Health
  • CALIFORNIA HEALTH FOUNDATION AND TRUST
  • California Hospitals Committee on Issues, (CHCI) Sponsored by California Association of Hospitals and Health Systems
  • AHMC Healthcare, Inc
  • California Association of Hospitals and Health Systems

Opposing: Service Employees International Union, United Healthcare Workers West (NonProfit 501 (C)(5))