Capitol Daybook Research
← All ballot measures

November 6, 2018 General Election

Proposition 5

Changes Requirements for Certain Property Owners to Transfer Their Property Tax Base to Replacement Property. Initiative Constitutional Amendment and Statute.

What it does

Proposition 5 would have expanded the rules allowing eligible homeowners to transfer the taxable value of their home to a replacement home. It would have allowed transfers anywhere in the state, allowed purchase of a more expensive home with an upward adjustment, and removed limits on how many times the transfer could be used. The Legislative Analyst estimated schools and other local governments would each lose over $100 million per year in the first few years, growing to about $1 billion per year each over time, with state costs for schools increasing by similar amounts.

Written from the Legislative Analyst's analysis of this measure.

Official summary

CHANGES REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTAIN PROPERTY OWNERS TO TRANSFER THEIR PROPERTY TAX BASE TO REPLACEMENT PROPERTY. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT AND STATUTE. Removes certain transfer requirements for homeowners over 55, severely disabled homeowners, and contaminated or disaster-destroyed property. Fiscal Impact: Schools and local governments each would lose over $100 million in annual property taxes early on, growing to about $1 billion per year. Similar increase in state costs to backfill school property tax losses.

The Attorney General's summary as printed for voters. Official voter guide

About this measure

How it qualified

Initiative constitutional amendment and statute. Initiative 17-0013A1, qualified by voter signatures.

Analysis and official text

Legislative Analyst's analysis · Official voter guide

Related measures

  • Proposition 37 (November 3, 2026 General Election) shared committee: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
  • Proposition 5 (November 5, 2024 General Election) shared committee: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
  • Proposition 33 (November 5, 2024 General Election) shared committee: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
  • Proposition 19 (November 3, 2020 General Election) shared committee + shared topic: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors; Property tax base transfers
  • Proposition 1 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee: East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5
  • Proposition 2 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee: East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5
  • Proposition 10 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee: East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5; Million Voter Project Action Fund, No on 5 Yes on 10, Sponsored by Social Justice Organizations

Related measures

Part of a recurring issue: Property tax base transfers. Also on the ballot in other elections: Proposition 19 (November 3, 2020 General Election): Passed.

Statewide result

YesNoYes shareMarginResult
4,813,2517,152,99340.22%No by 19.6 pts (2,339,742 votes)Failed

Certified statewide results, Secretary of State Statement of Vote.

Results by district

Assembly districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Assembly District 183,687110,16743.17%
Assembly District 259,076122,18832.59%
Assembly District 362,46592,01140.44%
Assembly District 461,759108,47636.28%
Assembly District 575,83398,44943.51%
Assembly District 6102,192121,84145.61%
Assembly District 748,084101,98132.04%
Assembly District 865,583103,31338.83%
Assembly District 957,62594,60337.85%
Assembly District 1070,999140,14333.63%
Assembly District 1163,87790,73041.32%
Assembly District 1264,01389,95841.57%
Assembly District 1341,15570,92836.72%
Assembly District 1463,440103,66437.96%
Assembly District 1549,683151,73024.67%
Assembly District 1694,945120,70944.03%
Assembly District 1744,207155,40622.15%
Assembly District 1846,560122,61127.52%
Assembly District 1954,217127,46529.84%
Assembly District 2051,33584,13937.89%
Assembly District 2141,33365,63738.64%
Assembly District 2270,702118,80137.31%
Assembly District 2356,809104,88635.13%
Assembly District 2463,722110,92336.49%
Assembly District 2553,59177,10341%
Assembly District 2642,03963,96339.66%
Assembly District 2745,76271,10639.16%
Assembly District 2876,803105,48542.13%
Assembly District 2973,239128,24036.35%
Assembly District 3047,23272,72239.38%
Assembly District 3127,48255,48933.12%
Assembly District 3226,35641,12339.06%
Assembly District 3357,60860,03348.97%
Assembly District 3467,43075,50747.17%
Assembly District 3573,91596,15043.46%
Assembly District 3659,47666,23347.31%
Assembly District 3771,259118,77937.5%
Assembly District 3890,59992,13449.58%
Assembly District 3941,62467,20538.25%
Assembly District 4058,96869,80245.79%
Assembly District 4174,995110,76440.37%
Assembly District 4273,05479,97047.74%
Assembly District 4353,028104,06633.76%
Assembly District 4473,52286,95845.81%
Assembly District 4562,45090,09140.94%
Assembly District 4645,51692,68432.93%
Assembly District 4739,87355,07342%
Assembly District 4850,53266,80743.06%
Assembly District 4944,21160,33942.29%
Assembly District 5067,209137,14032.89%
Assembly District 5133,18487,75327.44%
Assembly District 5244,69057,63643.67%
Assembly District 5324,72160,17729.12%
Assembly District 5448,327124,30527.99%
Assembly District 5583,57676,08952.34%
Assembly District 5636,88157,12839.23%
Assembly District 5755,85772,91843.38%
Assembly District 5848,79071,02840.72%
Assembly District 5923,53651,40731.41%
Assembly District 6060,11264,03648.42%
Assembly District 6149,13862,64443.96%
Assembly District 6246,723101,89331.44%
Assembly District 6336,72561,98937.2%
Assembly District 6433,32264,46234.08%
Assembly District 6560,69068,03247.15%
Assembly District 6679,33197,08144.97%
Assembly District 6779,56872,61552.28%
Assembly District 6890,88889,17750.48%
Assembly District 6934,56451,27440.27%
Assembly District 7056,14191,40538.05%
Assembly District 7184,40677,79752.04%
Assembly District 7277,89677,97349.98%
Assembly District 73109,78994,89153.64%
Assembly District 7495,477100,34048.76%
Assembly District 7584,11882,35150.53%
Assembly District 7679,37396,91645.02%
Assembly District 7789,635104,93746.07%
Assembly District 7870,508122,53636.52%
Assembly District 7962,18590,13640.82%
Assembly District 8042,02666,34238.78%

Senate districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
State Senate District 1187,901230,36344.92%
State Senate District 2126,292252,44733.35%
State Senate District 3127,834219,81636.77%
State Senate District 4133,789193,46540.88%
State Senate District 5105,915163,23139.35%
State Senate District 6106,648206,95934.01%
State Senate District 7158,696211,28942.89%
State Senate District 8127,881204,64838.46%
State Senate District 996,686274,95826.02%
State Senate District 10104,896163,20039.13%
State Senate District 1197,987282,00525.79%
State Senate District 1275,034123,31337.83%
State Senate District 13134,056229,53736.87%
State Senate District 1451,85289,53036.68%
State Senate District 15126,129178,60941.39%
State Senate District 16117,092141,55845.27%
State Senate District 17147,115229,20639.09%
State Senate District 1887,364160,41435.26%
State Senate District 19123,244187,39039.67%
State Senate District 2084,563112,70942.87%
State Senate District 21126,786136,08948.23%
State Senate District 2286,863121,86941.61%
State Senate District 23139,382146,05548.83%
State Senate District 2458,854158,12427.12%
State Senate District 25134,940203,57039.86%
State Senate District 26144,711254,69036.23%
State Senate District 27161,786194,32545.43%
State Senate District 28137,104149,31047.87%
State Senate District 29141,953142,51649.9%
State Senate District 3072,855180,37928.77%
State Senate District 31109,250126,68046.31%
State Senate District 32111,622149,91142.68%
State Senate District 3370,440127,80535.53%
State Senate District 34119,399138,84546.23%
State Senate District 3582,678149,91635.55%
State Senate District 36191,271193,60649.7%
State Senate District 37187,491190,43249.61%
State Senate District 38172,097172,56549.93%
State Senate District 39150,758228,14039.79%
State Senate District 4092,037133,51940.8%

Congressional districts

DistrictYesNoYes share
Congressional District 1116,619162,31841.81%
Congressional District 2101,605203,30133.32%
Congressional District 387,619137,02739%
Congressional District 4147,067179,85144.99%
Congressional District 593,978168,74535.77%
Congressional District 669,791147,16132.17%
Congressional District 7111,224163,97940.42%
Congressional District 890,55997,37048.19%
Congressional District 978,887118,34240%
Congressional District 1086,642126,91140.57%
Congressional District 11106,020168,78638.58%
Congressional District 1274,107234,73224%
Congressional District 1371,991220,69624.6%
Congressional District 1494,137164,90536.34%
Congressional District 1598,135141,31740.98%
Congressional District 1649,97588,77136.02%
Congressional District 1784,295120,55841.15%
Congressional District 18114,634180,04438.9%
Congressional District 1986,523128,35740.27%
Congressional District 2079,517143,77635.61%
Congressional District 2141,22469,09537.37%
Congressional District 2277,148136,33636.14%
Congressional District 2394,284106,51446.95%
Congressional District 24109,024163,90139.95%
Congressional District 25115,620121,14048.83%
Congressional District 26111,087139,71644.29%
Congressional District 2789,431135,83039.7%
Congressional District 2878,990165,84432.26%
Congressional District 2954,33997,85735.7%
Congressional District 3098,246156,68738.54%
Congressional District 3183,300100,88745.23%
Congressional District 3275,46299,72843.07%
Congressional District 33122,186183,93539.91%
Congressional District 3443,526111,37128.1%
Congressional District 3563,65683,73343.19%
Congressional District 3689,593110,42944.79%
Congressional District 3766,581165,96328.63%
Congressional District 3884,262114,37642.42%
Congressional District 39120,200117,42950.58%
Congressional District 4045,30178,74236.52%
Congressional District 4173,56291,55144.55%
Congressional District 42118,812109,89451.95%
Congressional District 4365,610126,52834.15%
Congressional District 4453,37396,05635.72%
Congressional District 45147,167146,53450.11%
Congressional District 4661,87082,81142.76%
Congressional District 4791,418124,77442.29%
Congressional District 48144,658138,20451.14%
Congressional District 49134,284148,79547.44%
Congressional District 50130,933122,15751.73%
Congressional District 5157,83290,85238.9%
Congressional District 52124,770160,74743.7%
ca-53102,177157,63039.33%

District lines in effect for this election (2011 lines).

Election results

2018 General Election: Yes took 40.2% statewide.

Precinct-level results and breakdowns are in the Election Reports.

Campaign finance

Finance data as of November 4, 2026, from Cal-Access.

Committees supporting

Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors

Committees opposing

East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5

Active on more than one measure; its committee-wide totals are not attributed to this measure.

Million Voter Project Action Fund, No on 5, Sponsored by Social Justice Organizations

Million Voter Project Action Fund, No on 5, Yes on 10, Sponsored by Social Justice Organizations

Active on more than one measure; its committee-wide totals are not attributed to this measure.

No on Prop 5, Sponsored by Educators, Public Safety and Health Care Organizations

Committee totals, top funders, and late independent expenditures are part of the research access layer.

Who funded the campaigns

The largest committee on each side of this measure, and that committee's largest funders in the Secretary of State filings compiled for this library.

Supporting: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors

  • CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS ISSUES MOBILIZATION PAC
  • NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS
  • National Associaton of Realtors

Opposing: No on Prop 5, Sponsored by Educators, Public Safety and Health Care Organizations

  • CALIFORNIA STATE COUNCIL OF SERVICE EMPLOYEES' PAC
  • California Teachers Association Issues PAC
  • American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
  • California Professional Firefighters Ballot Issues Committee
  • CALIFORNIA FEDERATION OF TEACHERS COPE PROP/BALLOT COMMITTEE