← All ballot measuresNovember 6, 2018 General Election
Proposition 5
Changes Requirements for Certain Property Owners to Transfer Their Property Tax Base to Replacement Property. Initiative Constitutional Amendment and Statute.
What it does
Proposition 5 would have expanded the rules allowing eligible homeowners to transfer the taxable value of their home to a replacement home. It would have allowed transfers anywhere in the state, allowed purchase of a more expensive home with an upward adjustment, and removed limits on how many times the transfer could be used. The Legislative Analyst estimated schools and other local governments would each lose over $100 million per year in the first few years, growing to about $1 billion per year each over time, with state costs for schools increasing by similar amounts.
Written from the Legislative Analyst's analysis of this measure.
Official summary
CHANGES REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTAIN PROPERTY OWNERS TO TRANSFER THEIR PROPERTY TAX BASE TO REPLACEMENT PROPERTY. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT AND STATUTE. Removes certain transfer requirements for homeowners over 55, severely disabled homeowners, and contaminated or disaster-destroyed property. Fiscal Impact: Schools and local governments each would lose over $100 million in annual property taxes early on, growing to about $1 billion per year. Similar increase in state costs to backfill school property tax losses.
The Attorney General's summary as printed for voters. Official voter guide
About this measure
How it qualified
Initiative constitutional amendment and statute. Initiative 17-0013A1, qualified by voter signatures.
Analysis and official text
Legislative Analyst's analysis · Official voter guide
Related measures
- Proposition 37 (November 3, 2026 General Election) shared committee: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
- Proposition 5 (November 5, 2024 General Election) shared committee: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
- Proposition 33 (November 5, 2024 General Election) shared committee: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
- Proposition 19 (November 3, 2020 General Election) shared committee + shared topic: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors; Property tax base transfers
- Proposition 1 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee: East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5
- Proposition 2 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee: East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5
- Proposition 10 (November 6, 2018 General Election) shared committee: East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5; Million Voter Project Action Fund, No on 5 Yes on 10, Sponsored by Social Justice Organizations
Related measures
Part of a recurring issue: Property tax base transfers. Also on the ballot in other elections: Proposition 19 (November 3, 2020 General Election): Passed.
Statewide result
| Yes | No | Yes share | Margin | Result |
|---|
| 4,813,251 | 7,152,993 | 40.22% | No by 19.6 pts (2,339,742 votes) | Failed |
Certified statewide results, Secretary of State Statement of Vote.
Results by district
Assembly districts
| District | Yes | No | Yes share |
|---|
| Assembly District 1 | 83,687 | 110,167 | 43.17% |
| Assembly District 2 | 59,076 | 122,188 | 32.59% |
| Assembly District 3 | 62,465 | 92,011 | 40.44% |
| Assembly District 4 | 61,759 | 108,476 | 36.28% |
| Assembly District 5 | 75,833 | 98,449 | 43.51% |
| Assembly District 6 | 102,192 | 121,841 | 45.61% |
| Assembly District 7 | 48,084 | 101,981 | 32.04% |
| Assembly District 8 | 65,583 | 103,313 | 38.83% |
| Assembly District 9 | 57,625 | 94,603 | 37.85% |
| Assembly District 10 | 70,999 | 140,143 | 33.63% |
| Assembly District 11 | 63,877 | 90,730 | 41.32% |
| Assembly District 12 | 64,013 | 89,958 | 41.57% |
| Assembly District 13 | 41,155 | 70,928 | 36.72% |
| Assembly District 14 | 63,440 | 103,664 | 37.96% |
| Assembly District 15 | 49,683 | 151,730 | 24.67% |
| Assembly District 16 | 94,945 | 120,709 | 44.03% |
| Assembly District 17 | 44,207 | 155,406 | 22.15% |
| Assembly District 18 | 46,560 | 122,611 | 27.52% |
| Assembly District 19 | 54,217 | 127,465 | 29.84% |
| Assembly District 20 | 51,335 | 84,139 | 37.89% |
| Assembly District 21 | 41,333 | 65,637 | 38.64% |
| Assembly District 22 | 70,702 | 118,801 | 37.31% |
| Assembly District 23 | 56,809 | 104,886 | 35.13% |
| Assembly District 24 | 63,722 | 110,923 | 36.49% |
| Assembly District 25 | 53,591 | 77,103 | 41% |
| Assembly District 26 | 42,039 | 63,963 | 39.66% |
| Assembly District 27 | 45,762 | 71,106 | 39.16% |
| Assembly District 28 | 76,803 | 105,485 | 42.13% |
| Assembly District 29 | 73,239 | 128,240 | 36.35% |
| Assembly District 30 | 47,232 | 72,722 | 39.38% |
| Assembly District 31 | 27,482 | 55,489 | 33.12% |
| Assembly District 32 | 26,356 | 41,123 | 39.06% |
| Assembly District 33 | 57,608 | 60,033 | 48.97% |
| Assembly District 34 | 67,430 | 75,507 | 47.17% |
| Assembly District 35 | 73,915 | 96,150 | 43.46% |
| Assembly District 36 | 59,476 | 66,233 | 47.31% |
| Assembly District 37 | 71,259 | 118,779 | 37.5% |
| Assembly District 38 | 90,599 | 92,134 | 49.58% |
| Assembly District 39 | 41,624 | 67,205 | 38.25% |
| Assembly District 40 | 58,968 | 69,802 | 45.79% |
| Assembly District 41 | 74,995 | 110,764 | 40.37% |
| Assembly District 42 | 73,054 | 79,970 | 47.74% |
| Assembly District 43 | 53,028 | 104,066 | 33.76% |
| Assembly District 44 | 73,522 | 86,958 | 45.81% |
| Assembly District 45 | 62,450 | 90,091 | 40.94% |
| Assembly District 46 | 45,516 | 92,684 | 32.93% |
| Assembly District 47 | 39,873 | 55,073 | 42% |
| Assembly District 48 | 50,532 | 66,807 | 43.06% |
| Assembly District 49 | 44,211 | 60,339 | 42.29% |
| Assembly District 50 | 67,209 | 137,140 | 32.89% |
| Assembly District 51 | 33,184 | 87,753 | 27.44% |
| Assembly District 52 | 44,690 | 57,636 | 43.67% |
| Assembly District 53 | 24,721 | 60,177 | 29.12% |
| Assembly District 54 | 48,327 | 124,305 | 27.99% |
| Assembly District 55 | 83,576 | 76,089 | 52.34% |
| Assembly District 56 | 36,881 | 57,128 | 39.23% |
| Assembly District 57 | 55,857 | 72,918 | 43.38% |
| Assembly District 58 | 48,790 | 71,028 | 40.72% |
| Assembly District 59 | 23,536 | 51,407 | 31.41% |
| Assembly District 60 | 60,112 | 64,036 | 48.42% |
| Assembly District 61 | 49,138 | 62,644 | 43.96% |
| Assembly District 62 | 46,723 | 101,893 | 31.44% |
| Assembly District 63 | 36,725 | 61,989 | 37.2% |
| Assembly District 64 | 33,322 | 64,462 | 34.08% |
| Assembly District 65 | 60,690 | 68,032 | 47.15% |
| Assembly District 66 | 79,331 | 97,081 | 44.97% |
| Assembly District 67 | 79,568 | 72,615 | 52.28% |
| Assembly District 68 | 90,888 | 89,177 | 50.48% |
| Assembly District 69 | 34,564 | 51,274 | 40.27% |
| Assembly District 70 | 56,141 | 91,405 | 38.05% |
| Assembly District 71 | 84,406 | 77,797 | 52.04% |
| Assembly District 72 | 77,896 | 77,973 | 49.98% |
| Assembly District 73 | 109,789 | 94,891 | 53.64% |
| Assembly District 74 | 95,477 | 100,340 | 48.76% |
| Assembly District 75 | 84,118 | 82,351 | 50.53% |
| Assembly District 76 | 79,373 | 96,916 | 45.02% |
| Assembly District 77 | 89,635 | 104,937 | 46.07% |
| Assembly District 78 | 70,508 | 122,536 | 36.52% |
| Assembly District 79 | 62,185 | 90,136 | 40.82% |
| Assembly District 80 | 42,026 | 66,342 | 38.78% |
Senate districts
| District | Yes | No | Yes share |
|---|
| State Senate District 1 | 187,901 | 230,363 | 44.92% |
| State Senate District 2 | 126,292 | 252,447 | 33.35% |
| State Senate District 3 | 127,834 | 219,816 | 36.77% |
| State Senate District 4 | 133,789 | 193,465 | 40.88% |
| State Senate District 5 | 105,915 | 163,231 | 39.35% |
| State Senate District 6 | 106,648 | 206,959 | 34.01% |
| State Senate District 7 | 158,696 | 211,289 | 42.89% |
| State Senate District 8 | 127,881 | 204,648 | 38.46% |
| State Senate District 9 | 96,686 | 274,958 | 26.02% |
| State Senate District 10 | 104,896 | 163,200 | 39.13% |
| State Senate District 11 | 97,987 | 282,005 | 25.79% |
| State Senate District 12 | 75,034 | 123,313 | 37.83% |
| State Senate District 13 | 134,056 | 229,537 | 36.87% |
| State Senate District 14 | 51,852 | 89,530 | 36.68% |
| State Senate District 15 | 126,129 | 178,609 | 41.39% |
| State Senate District 16 | 117,092 | 141,558 | 45.27% |
| State Senate District 17 | 147,115 | 229,206 | 39.09% |
| State Senate District 18 | 87,364 | 160,414 | 35.26% |
| State Senate District 19 | 123,244 | 187,390 | 39.67% |
| State Senate District 20 | 84,563 | 112,709 | 42.87% |
| State Senate District 21 | 126,786 | 136,089 | 48.23% |
| State Senate District 22 | 86,863 | 121,869 | 41.61% |
| State Senate District 23 | 139,382 | 146,055 | 48.83% |
| State Senate District 24 | 58,854 | 158,124 | 27.12% |
| State Senate District 25 | 134,940 | 203,570 | 39.86% |
| State Senate District 26 | 144,711 | 254,690 | 36.23% |
| State Senate District 27 | 161,786 | 194,325 | 45.43% |
| State Senate District 28 | 137,104 | 149,310 | 47.87% |
| State Senate District 29 | 141,953 | 142,516 | 49.9% |
| State Senate District 30 | 72,855 | 180,379 | 28.77% |
| State Senate District 31 | 109,250 | 126,680 | 46.31% |
| State Senate District 32 | 111,622 | 149,911 | 42.68% |
| State Senate District 33 | 70,440 | 127,805 | 35.53% |
| State Senate District 34 | 119,399 | 138,845 | 46.23% |
| State Senate District 35 | 82,678 | 149,916 | 35.55% |
| State Senate District 36 | 191,271 | 193,606 | 49.7% |
| State Senate District 37 | 187,491 | 190,432 | 49.61% |
| State Senate District 38 | 172,097 | 172,565 | 49.93% |
| State Senate District 39 | 150,758 | 228,140 | 39.79% |
| State Senate District 40 | 92,037 | 133,519 | 40.8% |
Congressional districts
| District | Yes | No | Yes share |
|---|
| Congressional District 1 | 116,619 | 162,318 | 41.81% |
| Congressional District 2 | 101,605 | 203,301 | 33.32% |
| Congressional District 3 | 87,619 | 137,027 | 39% |
| Congressional District 4 | 147,067 | 179,851 | 44.99% |
| Congressional District 5 | 93,978 | 168,745 | 35.77% |
| Congressional District 6 | 69,791 | 147,161 | 32.17% |
| Congressional District 7 | 111,224 | 163,979 | 40.42% |
| Congressional District 8 | 90,559 | 97,370 | 48.19% |
| Congressional District 9 | 78,887 | 118,342 | 40% |
| Congressional District 10 | 86,642 | 126,911 | 40.57% |
| Congressional District 11 | 106,020 | 168,786 | 38.58% |
| Congressional District 12 | 74,107 | 234,732 | 24% |
| Congressional District 13 | 71,991 | 220,696 | 24.6% |
| Congressional District 14 | 94,137 | 164,905 | 36.34% |
| Congressional District 15 | 98,135 | 141,317 | 40.98% |
| Congressional District 16 | 49,975 | 88,771 | 36.02% |
| Congressional District 17 | 84,295 | 120,558 | 41.15% |
| Congressional District 18 | 114,634 | 180,044 | 38.9% |
| Congressional District 19 | 86,523 | 128,357 | 40.27% |
| Congressional District 20 | 79,517 | 143,776 | 35.61% |
| Congressional District 21 | 41,224 | 69,095 | 37.37% |
| Congressional District 22 | 77,148 | 136,336 | 36.14% |
| Congressional District 23 | 94,284 | 106,514 | 46.95% |
| Congressional District 24 | 109,024 | 163,901 | 39.95% |
| Congressional District 25 | 115,620 | 121,140 | 48.83% |
| Congressional District 26 | 111,087 | 139,716 | 44.29% |
| Congressional District 27 | 89,431 | 135,830 | 39.7% |
| Congressional District 28 | 78,990 | 165,844 | 32.26% |
| Congressional District 29 | 54,339 | 97,857 | 35.7% |
| Congressional District 30 | 98,246 | 156,687 | 38.54% |
| Congressional District 31 | 83,300 | 100,887 | 45.23% |
| Congressional District 32 | 75,462 | 99,728 | 43.07% |
| Congressional District 33 | 122,186 | 183,935 | 39.91% |
| Congressional District 34 | 43,526 | 111,371 | 28.1% |
| Congressional District 35 | 63,656 | 83,733 | 43.19% |
| Congressional District 36 | 89,593 | 110,429 | 44.79% |
| Congressional District 37 | 66,581 | 165,963 | 28.63% |
| Congressional District 38 | 84,262 | 114,376 | 42.42% |
| Congressional District 39 | 120,200 | 117,429 | 50.58% |
| Congressional District 40 | 45,301 | 78,742 | 36.52% |
| Congressional District 41 | 73,562 | 91,551 | 44.55% |
| Congressional District 42 | 118,812 | 109,894 | 51.95% |
| Congressional District 43 | 65,610 | 126,528 | 34.15% |
| Congressional District 44 | 53,373 | 96,056 | 35.72% |
| Congressional District 45 | 147,167 | 146,534 | 50.11% |
| Congressional District 46 | 61,870 | 82,811 | 42.76% |
| Congressional District 47 | 91,418 | 124,774 | 42.29% |
| Congressional District 48 | 144,658 | 138,204 | 51.14% |
| Congressional District 49 | 134,284 | 148,795 | 47.44% |
| Congressional District 50 | 130,933 | 122,157 | 51.73% |
| Congressional District 51 | 57,832 | 90,852 | 38.9% |
| Congressional District 52 | 124,770 | 160,747 | 43.7% |
| ca-53 | 102,177 | 157,630 | 39.33% |
District lines in effect for this election (2011 lines).
Election results
2018 General Election: Yes took 40.2% statewide.
Precinct-level results and breakdowns are in the Election Reports.
Campaign finance
Finance data as of November 4, 2026, from Cal-Access.
Committees supporting
Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
Committees opposing
East Bay Housing Organizations (Non Profit 501C3) - Yes on Props 1, 2 & 10 & No on Prop 5
Active on more than one measure; its committee-wide totals are not attributed to this measure.
Million Voter Project Action Fund, No on 5, Sponsored by Social Justice Organizations
Million Voter Project Action Fund, No on 5, Yes on 10, Sponsored by Social Justice Organizations
Active on more than one measure; its committee-wide totals are not attributed to this measure.
No on Prop 5, Sponsored by Educators, Public Safety and Health Care Organizations
Committee totals, top funders, and late independent expenditures are part of the research access layer.
Who funded the campaigns
The largest committee on each side of this measure, and that committee's largest funders in the Secretary of State filings compiled for this library.
Supporting: Yes on 5 Committee, Sponsored by the California Association of Realtors
- CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS ISSUES MOBILIZATION PAC
- NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS
- National Associaton of Realtors
Opposing: No on Prop 5, Sponsored by Educators, Public Safety and Health Care Organizations
- CALIFORNIA STATE COUNCIL OF SERVICE EMPLOYEES' PAC
- California Teachers Association Issues PAC
- American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
- California Professional Firefighters Ballot Issues Committee
- CALIFORNIA FEDERATION OF TEACHERS COPE PROP/BALLOT COMMITTEE